Why You Should Be Grading Yourself After Practice

Why You Should Be Grading Yourself After Practice

The way things go for you on race day is decided by the average of how your swim practices go. Here’s how grading your workouts will help you be more consistent in practice.

I’m buzzing right now while writing this.

Not because I had too much coffee, or because I am excited for NCAA’s this week.

The reason is I had myself one of those workouts that exceeded expectations earlier this afternoon.

Despite the soreness in the traps, shoulders and wherever else I can still feel things, there is a warm buzz flowing through me. You know the combo: a mental buzz of accomplishment combined with a grotesque amount of soreness and fatigue.

And yet… Feels pretty darn good.

Having an above average workout in the water tends to make us feel this way.

Which got me thinking…

We tend to judge our swimming by the extremes.

If we have a great swim workout we feel like we are on top of the world, everything is A-OK, and our goals are gonna get it real bad at the end of the year.

In the same vein, if we have a stinky stinkerton workout our confidence and belief fall butt-first through the floor into the basement.

Extremes are shock events: they stick out like crazy.

Especially the bad ones (this isn’t accidental or weird, we are purposely wired to “better” remember bad events). And because they stick out so much, we end up labeling our swimming and the prospects of future success on the basis of them.

It’s why one bad workout can so easily turn into a couple bad workouts, which dovetails into a week of bad workouts.

But the extremes don’t tell the story.

That one brutal workout doesn’t mean your season is over and that your improvement is going backwards.

Not even close.

What’s your practice average? What’s the average grade of your recent workouts?

A better way to approach and attack your workouts is with a focus on doing it better than average.

Your average.

After all, the way that things go down on race day is a reflection of the average of our training.

Read that again.

The way things go down on race day is a reflection of the average of our training.

And not only just how our practices go, but the average how much sleep we get. The average of how well we manage stress and anxiety. The average of how tuned up our nutrition is.

This is just another reason I am so keen on grading my workouts after I get out of the water.

A simple 1-10 rating is what I’ve used since the age of 12, but I’ve seen swimmers use letter grades, smiley faces, blue stars, and so on to rate their workouts.

Why You Should Grade Your Workouts

There are some better-than-average (ha!) reasons to keep track of your own average:

1. It keeps the extreme workouts in perspective.

Sure, I know I am going to flunk the occasional workout. Even though today went great, there is a real possibility that tomorrow’s workout could always end being a big, stinky old “F” or “Incomplete”.

Supercharge Your Mindset (and Your Swimming)

Mental training finally made simple. Get mentally tougher, choke-proof your races, seriously escalate self-confidence, and much more.

Used by some of the top swimmers and coaches on the planet, Conquer the Pool is the swimmer’s ultimate weapon for a better mindset and faster swimming.

Learn More

Just like I know occasionally I’m gonna have the random A+ where I nearly beat a personal best time in practice. But those are the outliers.

Instead, figure out your average (8/10 seems to be mine over the past couple weeks), and focus on finishing each workout so that you can dry off your hands and jot down an 8 or better.

Focusing on your average keeps your highs from launching you into space while keeping the lows from crushing your confidence.

2. Gives you something doable to achieve each day in practice.

When we hold up the A+ practice as the expectation we are setting ourselves up to fail. It’s not that it’s aiming for those perfect workouts isn’t admirable—big expectations are important.

But realistically, we both know that those epic workouts aren’t going to happen every day. We aren’t going to smash up our in-practice best times every day. (As nice as that might be to fantasize about.)

Sky-high expectations are only as productive as the motivation they provide.

If your expectation is having an A+ workout every day, and then you consistently don’t meet that standard, it won’t be long before you’re left feeling discouraged and demoralized. This is one of those moments you need to be honest with yourself about expectations doing more harm than good.

But hitting your average best in practice?

That is something you can do (almost) every day.

Too often the barrier to doing the things that need doing is perfection; having a realistic target to aim for each day in the water makes it far more likely that you will start and give the workout a high-grade effort.

3. Gives you a barometer for course change.

If you are consistently falling below your average, something’s up.

Maybe you are too stressed and not taking the time to de-stress between school and swimming. Perhaps your sleeping habits have fallen by the wayside because of new social activities. Or you are simply treating your mouth-hole like a dumpster instead of the high-performance Ferrari intake valve that it is.

Streaks of below average workouts is a sign something is up and is a red flag that you need to reassess how you are treating your body and mind.

4. Keeps you focused on today.

I’ve experienced this personally and with other swimmers so many times it makes my face hurt:

One bad workout = My season is screwed, I am never going to achieve my goals, my competition is going to trounce me, and therefore I should storm off and allow another couple days of training go to waste.

Really bad workouts make us feel like the result (the big meet, the championship swim, the record, qualifying for a team, etc) is in jeopardy, possibly lost.

This result-focused, uh, focus, knocks us off course, and keeps us from getting dialed in on what we need to do to be excellent today.

Locking in on making the most of today’s practice so that you can score yourself a better-than-average mark becomes the priority and center of focus, not the meet that is months away.

What’s the next step?


Grab a piece of paper, open up a new text file on your phone, start a new calendar, open your log book

And grade your workout today.


The day after that.

Not only will you start having better practices immediately (wanting the reward of getting to write out a better score will give you a boost in practice), but you will quickly see where your average rests.

We all judge our swimming differently, so give it a week or two and see where you land.

Using that score, move forward with your training, striving to exceed it as often as possible.

Give it a try and let me know how it goes.

More Stuff Like This:

This Mental Training Workbook Will Help You Swim Like a Rock Star This Season. Confused about mental training? Want to unleash pro mode on your swimming this year? Learn how this mental training workbook will change your mindset and help you pummel your PB’s this season.

Why Change is So Hard in the Pool (and How to Make It Easier). We all want change in some measure—so why is it so dang difficult to make happen? Here’s the reality behind making change that actually sticks in the pool.

Get Daily Tips on How to Swim Faster

Subscribe to the YourSwimLog.com newsletter and get tips and advice on how to swim faster every weekday morning, straight to your inbox. 

Join 33,000+ swimmers, coaches, and swim parents learning what it takes to swim like a boss.

Unsubscribe anytime. Email will never be shared or sold.

Olivier Poirier-Leroy Olivier Poirier-Leroy is the founder of YourSwimLog.com. He is an author, former national level swimmer, two-time Olympic Trials qualifier, and swim coach.

Related Articles

Jack Alexy Swimmer - Mindset and Training Tips
Mental Training

5 Mindset Tips from Jack Alexy for Faster Swimming

Looking to take your mindset and swimming to the next level? Here are five things you can learn from Jack Alexy, one of the fastest freestylers on the planet. American Jack Alexy has joined the ranks of elite sprinters in the world. Now 21 years of age and standing a

Read More »
Journaling Prompts for Swimmers
Mental Training

21 Journaling Prompts for Swimmers

Feeling stuck with your journaling? Here are some journaling prompts for swimmers to build self-awareness, confidence, and help swimmers maintain perspective over the course of the swim season.

Read More »
The Importance of Having a Powerful Why for Your Swimming
Mental Training

The Importance of Having a Powerful Why for Swimmers

Swimmers invest a lot of time in the water over the course of the season. The two-a-days, long swim meets, and the perpetual sogginess can be difficult to bear for even the most motivated of swimmers. In the moments when you are struggling with commitment or motivation, it’s a great

Read More »